1956 Eisenhower VS. Stevenson
The Living Room Candidate
"Quail Hunting," Stevenson, 1956
[TEXT: HOW'S THAT AGAIN, GENERAL?]
MALE NARRATOR: How's that again, General? At a press conference and talking about his responsibilities as President, Mr: Eisenhower declared:
EISENHOWER: No President can delegate his constitutional duties. How can he do it? He has to sign the papers. He has to sign them, and he's responsible for them. I'm the responsible head of the executive part of this government.
MALE NARRATOR: How's that again, General?
EISENHOWER: I'm the responsible head of the executive part of this government.
KEFAUVER: This is Estes Kefauver. The words you have just heard turned out to be hollow words, indeed. At the height of the Dien Bien Phu Crisis, the President went quail hunting. When John Foster Dulles's "Brink of War" article confused the free world, the General ducked the responsibility: said he hadn't even read the article. And so it goes. The list of such actions or lack of actions is endless. The Presidency requires leadership, not buck-passing. Let's think it through.
MALE NARRATOR: Vote for Stevenson and Kefauver! Vote Democratic!
[TEXT: Vote for ADLAI STEVENSON and ESTES KEFAUVER]
"Quail Hunting," Stevenson, 1956Video courtesy of the John F. Kennedy Presidential Library.
From Museum of the Moving Image, The Living Room Candidate: Presidential Campaign Commercials 1952-2012.
www.livingroomcandidate.org/commercials/1956/quail-hunting (accessed September 24, 2020).
For President Eisenhower, the only true emergency of his first term was the heart attack he suffered in September 1955. After his doctor pronounced him fully recovered in February 1956, Eisenhower announced his decision to run for re-election. The Democrats set up a replay of the 1952 contest by nominating Adlai Stevenson. The result was an even greater Republican landslide. Eisenhower was a popular incumbent president who had ended the Korean War. Two world crises helped cement his lead in the final days of the campaign: the Soviet Union invaded Hungary, and Britain, France, and Israel attacked Egypt in an effort to take over the Suez Canal. Eisenhower kept the United States out of both conflicts. As is traditional during a military crisis, American voters rallied behind their president. The events also undermined two of Stevenson’s key positions: the suspension of hydrogen-bomb testing and the elimination of the military draft.
Richard Nixon for vice president
"Peace, Prosperity, and Progress"
Although Eisenhower was the incumbent president, his 1956 ads continued to portray him as an ordinary American. Capitalizing on his enormous popularity, they emphasized Ike’s personality even more than his accomplishments.
To counter Stevenson’s claim that the Democratic party was the party of the average American and the Republican "the party of the few," Eisenhower’s ads offered the testimony of ordinary citizens, whether in the dramatized ad "
The Eisenhower ads closed with an appeal to "all thinking voters" because a Republican victory was only possible with the support of Democrats and independents, who outnumbered Republicans in the general population. Conversely, Stevenson’s ads urged voters to uphold party loyalty, a common plea by Democratic candidates trailing in the polls.
Estes Kefauver for vice president
"Vote Democratic, the Party for You, and Not Just a Few"
In 1956, Adlai Stevenson was still publicly railing against the expanding role of television in politics. Yet Stevenson knew that he couldn’t compete without television, and the Democratic National Committee tried to hire one of the leading Madison Avenue agencies to handle the campaign. The account was turned down by all of the large firms, who feared offending their big-business Republican clients, and was finally accepted by Norman, Craig and Kummel, an agency with little political experience that ranked 25th in billings.
The main innovation in the commercials of the 1956 campaign was the five-minute spot. Stevenson appeared in a series of such spots, titled "
The five-minute spot (actually four minutes and twenty seconds) resulted from cooperation between the networks and the candidates. Hoping to avoid the pre-emption of programs by half-hour speeches, the networks agreed to trim their shows to accommodate five-minute ads. To the candidates’ advantage, the spots were less expensive than half-hour broadcasts, and, as they could be sandwiched between popular programs, were likely to reach more viewers.